The house is just this side of disused railroad tracks that stretch diagonally across the suburban street, cutting the property into an awkward slice. The house is close to the street, squat, the side yard brownish. Tree stumps and uneven ground make places where leaves accumulate. The tiny garage hunches down where the back yard dives to the gravel path leading to the town pool.
I know the house because I grew up two blocks away on a cul-de-sac of split levels perched back on rectangular green lawns. I know the path because I walked it every day every summer until my father bought me a horse, then a car.
In my early 40s, I am living five blocks further away, and I get to know the house on the odd-angled lot again just a little because I push my babies in the small stroller along the sidewalk, and in the big all-terrain stroller along the pool path, and because I often jog slowly past the house alone at six a.m.
But I don’t pay the house much mind.
Until one chilly morning I’m jogging, and from about 75 feet away, I notice a tall figure in jeans and a hooded sweatshirt on the front porch. At first I think he’s working a stubborn front door key. I can’t see the man’s face, or his hands, but I know it’s a man from the height and heft. I slow to a walk.
Something glints from his hands, too long, too large for a key. Closer now, I hear him grunt, hear the scrape of metal against wood, see him put his shoulder into it. I still can’t see his face, but now I’ve seen that his hands are black. That he’s black.
At least that is what I tell myself later, about what I saw, and in what order.
I don’t know when, in the sequence of what I saw, I cross the road, duck behind a shrub, and dial the police, a number memorized at age five.
“There’s a man breaking into a house on Martin Road, the one next to the tracks.”
I will always want to believe that I decided to call in the millisecond I realized he was trying to get into a door for which he did not possess a key, and not in the millisecond I noticed he was black.
The officer on the phone asks for a description.
“Tall, grey sweatshirt,” I say. “Black,” I say.
In seconds, sirens howl. I keep my eyes on the man, who doesn’t drop the tool, does not run off, does not seem even to hear. In a moment, some six police cars arrive, and now the man must hear because he freezes, and several policemen approach the house, one with gun drawn. At least that’s what I will remember, all the while thinking, I didn’t even know our little town had that many police cars.
The man drops something on the porch floor and turns, slowly, hands palms up in front of him. “Wait, I live here. I locked myself out. I was trying to get back in without waking my wife and baby.”
An officer asks his name, then pats the man down, extracts a wallet, pulls out something—a driver’s license I guess—and studies it. All but one of the cars leave, and a woman opens the front door, hand to her mouth.
The officer passes the wallet back, explains that someone called. I hear the black man say, “I understand. Thanks for checking things out.”
The police leave. The man and wife go inside. The image of his hand on her back against her yellow bathrobe stays with me.
I hide for a little while more. Then I cross the street, ring the doorbell. It was me who called the police, I’m sorry, I feel terrible. He nods, says he understands, tries to make a joke: “Well, I don’t feel great either, knowing someone can break in my house with my wife’s garden tools.”
But I know none of it is a joke, and ten years later when I hear about police in Cambridge and Henry Louis Gates, I remember and feel, somehow, complicit. I remember. I try to recall when, in the sequence in my head—man, tool, grunting, black—I decided to dial the police.
__
Lisa Romeo, a New Jersey resident, has completed a memoir, The Father and Daughter Reunion: Every Loss Story is a Love Story. Her nonfiction has been nominated for Best American Essays and a Pushcart, and has appeared in the New York Times, Under the Sun, Hippocampus, Sweet, Front Porch, Under the Gum Tree, and many other venues. Lisa holds an MFA from Stonecoast and a BS in journalism, and teaches in the Bay Path University MFA program. She is creative nonfiction editor of Compose.
Artwork by Damon Locks
14 comments
Terry Michael says:
Sep 12, 2016
What’s so striking about your essay is that your point of view isn’t just contrived, or written from a white-guilt perspective. It’s not the familiar upper-middle class feeling sorry for the brown-ish yard lower class. I love your essay because it’s honestly about all of those things. This is just plain ordinary real life beautifully captured. Returning to the house to apologize to the owner may strike some as phony, or self-congratulatory, the liberal “see how enlightened I am” stereotype. Not to me. For me, it tells the story of how we get caught in a lie – and how we come to terms with it. The lie? If you’re black, your face half-hidden, standing at a front door trying to enter it, you may be doing something bad. The Cambridge policeman who stopped Henry Louis Gates outside of his house also acted on a lie — he saw a black man maybe doing something bad in this “good” neighborhood. Many days after this happened, Gates agreed to meet with the policeman, and they talked. It was a generous thing for Gates to do. In this essay, the accuser apologizes to the homeowner, who graciously, and with great generosity, responds with humor, “Well, I don’t feel great either, knowing someone can break in my house with my wife’s garden tools.” You wrote straight from the heart of it, and from a truth we don’t always like to face. We screw up sometimes from the lies passed down to us, so go make it right.
ryder ziebarth says:
Sep 12, 2016
I like the tense this essay is written in, and I like the rhythm of the sentences, the intensity of the detail, the sounds and the visuals. But the utter truth of this piece is what sticks with me–the honestly in which you tell the story and your part in it, the way you don’t really know, and the way you doubt yourself. Beautifully done.
angie says:
Sep 13, 2016
love the recall of the story , makes it rather interesting
green diva meg says:
Sep 13, 2016
well-written! love your honest accounting and that you knocked on their door and owned it. great stuff.
Nicole Moliere says:
Sep 13, 2016
Great piece. Thank you.
Marie Mack says:
Sep 13, 2016
Wonderful! Thanks for sharing.
Lynn Sunday says:
Sep 16, 2016
Lynn Sunday says: Well written piece. Love your honest analysis of your motivations, and that you knocked on their door to own what you did.
Lisa Romeo says:
Sep 22, 2016
Thanks! I appreciate your reading and taking the time to leave such kind words.
Lauri Meyers says:
Oct 6, 2016
I love your honest portrayal, the reality of the non-entirely-fact which happens in the mind, and the current relevance of the story.
Jayne Martin says:
Oct 18, 2016
Lisa, this is so relatable and I appreciate the honest, straight-forward style of your prose. Perfect for this telling. Congratulations.
Rebecca Gummere says:
Oct 20, 2016
Lovely. Measured and honest. Standing there with you, I had to confess, to my sadness – I know I would have done the same thing. This awareness both hurts my heart and offers me the chance to grow into a better human being. Thanks for a beautiful read.
Robin Seibert says:
Oct 24, 2016
What a powerful story. From your opening sentence I was drawn in and wanted to know more. There was tension right there and I held my breath as I continued reading. Everything is to be admired here, least of all your bravery in ringing that doorbell. Oh the shame we all share in our immediate reactions. You made yourself so vulnerable here, Lisa, and for me, that’s incredibly inspiring. I’m leaving the piano now and headed straight for my desk. Thank you!
Jacqueline Wolven says:
Oct 24, 2016
That moment – is it because he is black or because she thinks he is breaking in – is when I fall into this story and the last paragraph is when my heart clenches. Well written and perfectly told.
Lori Dryer says:
Dec 7, 2016
The picture is perfect. It puts you right on that street that is so vividly described in this heart pulling story. She became aware of the ramifications of a split second call. The way she went back and apologized was huge. I honestly don’t know if I would have had the courage to do the same, but I know if I hadn’t, i would have always regretted it. What a beautifully written, thought provoking piece. Thank you for sharing this.