I am a grandmother of two middle-school-aged girls who call me “Granny,” and I darn socks. Not many people these days take the time to do it. People will throw holey socks away and buy new ones.
As I darn in my wooden rocking chair, I know that with my white hair I look like the traditional grandmother. On cold days, I even wrap a shawl around my shoulders.
As I rock and darn, my thoughts often circle around a sore spot, a hole in my life and the lives of my grandchildren: their mother, who died at age thirty-four from a heroin overdose. This was six years ago, when they were eight and six years old. If her loss is a hole in my long life, I can only imagine the crater it must be in theirs. They have never wanted to talk about it with me, not even right after it happened. The oldest, Molly, said my son told her she would be “surrounded by love,” and that’s the last thing either of them said about it to me. When I tried to bring it up after it happened, I was met with their shrieks: “Don’t talk about it!” And that’s the way it’s been.
My friend Kitty has a darning egg, an oval wooden ball she puts inside the heel of the sock. Heels are where most holes occur. Darning isn’t just bringing the two sides of the hole together; it’s actually weaving with new material, bits of yarn, creating more sock to replace what has been worn away. It took me some time to teach myself how to do it. At first, I wanted to sew the worn edges together. Gradually I realized that I needed to create a new fabric in the center. I push leftover yarn through the hole of a big darning needle and create a ladder of strings, not pulling the edges tight but looping across the hole. I cut and tie the yarn, then start again, creating another ladder crosswise to the first, slipping the needle above and below the first ladder. I go back and forth, changing directions until the repair looks sturdy enough to last for a while, then cut and tie it off.
Perhaps someday the girls will want to talk with me about their mother. What can I tell them? That she loved them? They know that, and they know the limits of that love, its inability to stretch beyond her death, or even beyond her addiction. I know there must be a part of each of them that is afraid that their mother’s fate awaits them, that they will die an unhappy early death. I want to tell them that won’t happen, but they know my knowledge is as limited as that of anyone.
There are some things that can’t be fixed. I will take them for ice cream and talk with them about whatever they want to talk about. I will watch their TikTok videos and give each one a heart. If they call me, I will answer no matter what. And maybe, over time, the weave will grow, not to make the hole disappear, but to make a strong enough web over it that they will be able to walk with confidence, and not fall through.
___
Patricia O’Donnell is Professor Emerita at the University of Maine at Farmington, where she taught Fiction Writing in the BFA Program. Her writing has appeared in The New Yorker, Agni Review, and many other places. Her most recent novel, The Vigilance of Stars, was chosen by the Maine Humanities Council to be discussed in libraries across the state; her novel A Symmetry of Husbands will be published this year by Unsolicited Press. More information can be found here: https://patriciaodonnell.weebly.com/
16 comments
Jan Priddy says:
Jan 18, 2023
Yes to this, so much about this. Yes to darning. Yes to the metaphor you make of it. Yes to the hope you bring to me personally. Thank you.
Wendy Oakley says:
Jan 18, 2023
A great analogy, recalling such a tragic event. I’m so sorry, Pat.
Robin Michel says:
Jan 20, 2023
Ms. O’Donnell, this is such a beautiful and moving essay. The language (and metaphor) is exquisite and the clear-eyed honesty in your writing “…they know my knowledge is as limited as that of anyone.” is so appreciated. I look forward to reading more of your work, and maybe purchasing a wooden egg and learning to darn myself. Thank you!
Patricia O'Donnell says:
Jan 25, 2023
Jan Priddy, Wendy Oakley, and Robin Michel, your words are much appreciated! One feels exposed, writing even such a short thing. Thank you for the affirmation.
Gretchen Legler says:
Jan 20, 2023
This is a perfect piece of nonfiction writing. This vignette exploring an everyday activity beautifully and effortlessly expands to reach beyond itself and become metaphor. Mending holes. The hole in the sock. The hole in the heart. It brought me to tears. What a wonderful and powerful essay!
Mary, your favorite sister says:
Jan 21, 2023
This brought me to tears Patty Lovely
Wesley McNair says:
Jan 22, 2023
Maybe you were always a “Granny.” I certainly recognize the sweet patience and wisdom of this speaker in your fiction. It was there from the start, giving a sense of hope for your characters, even those whose predicaments seemed intractable. Praise to the woman who darns in this essay and to the writer who has described her humble and faithful craft!
Carol C Wobig says:
Jan 23, 2023
A beautiful piece. Thank you.
Amanda Le Rougetel says:
Jan 24, 2023
Really moving: “And maybe, over time, the weave will grow, not to make the hole disappear, but to make a strong enough web over it that they will be able to walk with confidence, and not fall through.” I am sorry for your loss and grateful for your words.
Patricia O'Donnell says:
Jan 25, 2023
Wow, I wrote a comment above and after that, got to see all these other wonderful responses, from Gretchen, Mary (my favorite sister), Wes, Carol, and Amanda. What a treat, needed at the end of a difficult winter’s day! Much appreciated!
Genesis says:
Feb 13, 2023
This is beautiful. Its art.
Art Fahy says:
Feb 17, 2023
Thank you for your piece Darning. What a wonderful way you used Darning and and a tragic situation. The wound is there and can not be completely healed but with Love and hope “Granny” can get them through it.
william says:
Feb 21, 2023
Amazing essay.
loved it
Hayley says:
Mar 6, 2023
Beautiful. A perfect ending. I’m glad you have each other. God bless you!
Virginia Wittman says:
Mar 9, 2023
A beautiful piece! Loved the tie with darning. I want to learn that skill!
Harry says:
Apr 9, 2023
Powerful! Granny’s spider-like power is in her subtle presence: she darns moments and archaic granny objects into a protective web of evidence by which her granddaughters will know, years hence, that they were loved. Every detail counts. Even the ancient allusions and symbols buried in granny objects and actions find new life in the web of memory and meaning that is Granny’s essay.