I don’t remember every beating mom gave us. I just remember that we named them after All Star wrestling moves. She had an extensive repertoire of techniques. The Half Suplex. The Full Suplex. The Spine Buster. Also the body part specific moves: the Wrist Lock, Atomic Knee Drop, and Corner Butt Slam. Some included hardware, like the Lasso from El Paso, which was a leather belt with a welt-inducing metal buckle, and The Board of Ed, a maple yardstick with steel end caps.
We six kids had our own repertoire of tortures as well, those we gave each other: the Irish Kiss, the Hertz Donut, the Purple Nerple, the Indian Burn, the Stop Hittin’ Yourself, and the ever-popular Open Your Mouth and Close Your Eyes and You Shall Receive a Big Surprise.
It wasn’t until my younger sister Emily was removed from custody that it stopped. The Board of Ed left marks where teachers could find them. But by then I was the only child left at home, and I was starting to grow muscles.
Years later, when my siblings and I were all grown and had kids of our own to beat, I accompanied my mother to the doctor’s office to see the results of her CAT scan. He showed us an image of an enormous calcified tumor, an alabaster walnut that was crowding her right temporal lobe.
He asked her if she remembered ever being hit in the head, ever receiving a blow to her temple hard enough that it would cause a sliver of her skull to separate inward, the same way a shard of glass separates from a windshield when it’s been hit by a bb. He theorized that there was a shard of bone in the center of the mass, just as there is a grain of sand at the center of every pearl.
She said, “No, I can’t remember anything. I can’t even imagine what it would be.”
He said, “Are you sure? Perhaps a car accident. It would have caused a concussion. You may have been knocked unconscious.”
And again she said, “No, I don’t remember anything.”
But I remember perfectly well. My grandmother, proudly noting she was never one to spare the rod, told me herself what a bother my mother was: how she was sullen, how she burned the toast, spilled the juice, and failed in math. And for these infractions she was justly punished, with the rap on the knuckles, the slap on the jaw, the punch in the stomach, and the milk bottle to the side of the head.
—
Thaddeus Gunn lives in Seattle, Washington. You can read more of his work in the Spring 2014 issue of SmokeLong Quarterly. You can also hear him read during the 2014 AWP Conference in Seattle, Washington at “A Bang and a Smoke” at the Atlas Theater at 8PM on Thursday, February 27th.
21 comments
Debra Borchert says:
Jan 22, 2014
I am blown away. So much said in so few words with compassion and humor. The author shows forgiveness, empathy, understanding–all without telling. Such a powerful and tremendous piece. It stirs so many emotions and resounds.
Thank you for sharing your life.
injaynesworld says:
Jan 23, 2014
Family violence — the gift that keeps on giving. And yet the author managed to tell the story in such a deceptively matter-of-fact tone. Interesting contrast to the power of the content.
RZG says:
Jan 24, 2014
Wow. Just wow.
Mary Collins says:
Jan 24, 2014
Absolutely masterful.
Nouns of the Week III | Meghan McClure says:
Jan 24, 2014
[…] Slapstick. From the current issue of Brevity. Actually, read the whole […]
Thaddeus Gunn on Anger, Abuse, and “Slapstick” | BREVITY's Nonfiction Blog says:
Jan 30, 2014
[…] Thaddeus Gunn discusses the origins of his recent Brevity essay, “Slapstick“: […]
J.D. Roa says:
Jan 30, 2014
My brain tingled from reading this.
Darrelyn Saloom says:
Jan 31, 2014
So sad and beautifully told.
Thaddeus Gunn says:
Feb 1, 2014
Thank you all so very much. I truly appreciate your comments. Here’s a photograph of my mother in about 1935. http://imgur.com/rLsv1MY
Tiffany says:
Feb 7, 2018
That’s really heartbreaking – for all of you. My absolute sympathies for what your whole family has suffered. I hope that you have found your route to move beyond the old, dark family ways and find a new, happy world in your own family. You write with great compassion and with beauty in your sparse prose.
Courage says:
Feb 2, 2014
Thaddeus,
You wrote, in your *Brevity* post of 1/28/2014, “Abusers are many times among those you love the most and that you are the most eager to forgive.”
So true.
Such heartbreak — and heart — in both your essay and the later piece.
The effects are lifelong, yes. I too was the recipient of many blows to the head … and now live with the damage done; I functioned adequately in the ‘working world’ until one blow too many altered my capacities and competence below the ability to hide trauma’s cumulative effects.
No, your mother was not a monster … none of us are, though we can sweat out a lifetime in the work to see one another as otherwise. I’ve come to think of our violent potential and our choice to use it or not in this way: Do we choose to be humane, or merely human?
I realized at my mother’s deathbed, when I was 42, that I had forgiven her. I have never been so present, so fearless, as during the last hours of her life. I, her scapegoat, accompanied her to the threshold. Did she forgive me for being? I’ll never know. Have I forgiven myself? Mostly, no. The work goes on …
Thank you.
Ash says:
Mar 11, 2014
This story is a beautiful wrench to the heart. Thank you.
D. Howell says:
Mar 26, 2014
Beautiful and haunting.
My Writing Process Blog Tour | The Lyric Body says:
Aug 14, 2014
[…] rapt again—only this time it was at the participant readings where he shared his flash essay “Slapstick,” a piece as crisp and devastating as “La Bamba” had been joyous. Read his fiction and […]
Brevity’s Writing Process Blog Tour (with Bar Napkins) | BREVITY's Nonfiction Blog says:
Aug 28, 2014
[…] writer, and author of essays such as “My Life With The Bat Children” and “Slapstick.” Thaddeus was invited by Lauren Westerfield, newly-minted Assistant Essays editor at The […]
Beth Bates says:
Sep 1, 2014
Man. “Alabaster walnuts.” xo
Conni Crawford St. Angelo says:
Nov 1, 2014
Thad, I didn’t know. This is beautifully written, and heartbreaking. Congratulations on your Pushcart Prize nomination, it is well deserved. All my best to you, see you on FB.
janeydoe57 says:
Nov 4, 2014
This was stunning in its simplicity. My heart flinched a bit in kinship. Although I wasn’t beaten, my mother put me within reach of a sexually abusive grandfather. Yes, I forgave her. The grandfather not so much.
Congratulations on the nomination!
Judith L. Wachter says:
Nov 27, 2015
Dear Thad,
After reading your stories, I am even more grateful that you came to live with us when you did. I, of course, had no idea of the environment you were leaving. My hope is that you felt welcomed during your time with us and that it helped you in some way. Bless you and yours.
Paul Zakrzewski says:
Dec 24, 2016
Just heard this essay on the Brevity podcast (great job on that btw) — and had to find it on the page too. Stunning.
Thaddeus Gunn says:
May 7, 2021
Thank you so much, Debra. I really appreciate it. Sorry it took me 7 years to say thanks.