What hospice people do is coordinate. They coordinate my mother’s move from the hospital where she was taken unresponsive to the assisted living facility where she remains unresponsive. They coordinate the ambulance personnel who transfer her from the stretcher to the hospital bed whose rental and delivery they have also coordinated. They coordinate the schedule for the weekend nurse who checks her vitals and predicts it will just be a couple more days. In hospice language, my mother is actively dying, and they strive to coordinate that too.
They coordinate visits by a social worker for my father who lives in the assisted living facility with my mother and is concerned about her not eating. He is old and frail and spends much of his day supine on a queen-size bed in their room where the thermostat is set on high and the air oppressive because he won’t allow the windows to be opened. His mind is sharp, honed by the steady stream of thoughts and worries endlessly running through it. The social worker explains that unless my mother opens her eyes and asks for food, unless she can swallow, she cannot eat.
I can tell by his scowl and his silence, he doesn’t like the social worker. As soon as she’s gone, he turns to me and says, When I had my stroke, I couldn’t swallow. I know. I relearned in therapy. Why can’t they teach her like they taught me? She’s not conscious. When she wakes up. (Silence) Even if she did, she can’t follow instructions. While he digests this unpalatable fact, his aide helps him into his wheelchair and wheels him over to the rented hospital bed across from the queen-size one. He lays his head down by my mother’s unresponsive side and sobs, deep, gut-wrenching, body-wracking sobs.
Although his hands have lost their strength and dexterity, he can manage with one finger and sheer will to press the buttons on his phone. I am one of two numbers on his speed dial. Not long after I leave, he calls. Why won’t they give her water? She can’t swallow. What about on a teaspoon? You have to swallow even the tiniest amount of water. How can she survive without water? (Pause) She isn’t going to survive. I remind him she signed an advanced directive years ago when she was still lucid and knew what she was signing. This is not a conversation we should be having over the phone.
At her scheduled visit, the weekday hospice nurse will not commit to the couple of days the weekend nurse predicted. Vitals are better. In hospice language, my mother has rallied. She lies on her back in a semi-conscious state, blanket tucked under her armpits, raising and lowering one arm in a slow, gentle rhythm, as if conducting an orchestra in her sleep. My father lies on his bed, sneaker-clad feet propped on a pillow, interpreting each movement as a sign of recovery.
I can’t work, can’t think, can’t sleep. I never knew dying could take so long.
While my father is at lunch one day, I sit on the bed beside her and take her hand and tell her I forgive her lapses and shortcomings. I tell her I love her. I lean over to give her a kiss and feel the dry whisper of her lips move against my cheek, a startling and unexpected gesture. Did you just kiss me? Her eyes are closed but she nods with surprising vigor and with an audible smack, kisses me again. A definite and deliberate kiss.
Something long dormant stirs beneath my chest where my heart lies. I lay my head on her chest where her heart still beats.
This is what I will forever hold on to. The synchronicity of our hearts. The interlude of a kiss.
___
Peggy Duffy’s short stories and essays have appeared in Newsweek, The Washington Post, SmokeLong Quarterly, So To Speak, Wild Violet, Literary Mama, Brevity, and more, as well as in a number of themed anthologies. This is her first published piece since coming off of a ten-year writing hiatus, having been derailed by a career in commercial real estate. She lives outside Washington D.C. and is at work on a novel.
28 comments
Hayley says:
Sep 16, 2018
So beautiful, thank you for sharing this.
Helen says:
Sep 17, 2018
Evokes moments of my father’s death. Barely caught last whispers.
Britton Minor says:
Sep 17, 2018
Peggy, you tell your story with grace and aching beauty. This is when I couldn’t hold in my emotion any longer:
“I lean over to give her a kiss and feel the dry whisper of her lips move against my cheek, a startling and unexpected gesture. Did you just kiss me?”
And these parting lines leave me thinking of the crux of love’s power—its infinite ability to surprise and to somehow survive the long winters of neglect:
“Something long dormant stirs beneath my chest where my heart lies. I lay my head on her chest where her heart still beats.
This is what I will forever hold on to. The synchronicity of our hearts. The interlude of a kiss.”
I’m so moved—heartened that in these dark days of America we can be buoyed by the inexplicable beauty of a passing, (well told) and all it generates inside of us.
Lu Ann McNabb says:
Sep 17, 2018
Beautiful-it made me cry.
Mindy says:
Sep 17, 2018
This is one of the most beautiful and touching stories I have ever read. I can so relate to the experience. I’ve been there.
Valerie Shay says:
Sep 17, 2018
This is a beautiful tribute. Thank you for sharing this with us. Wonderfully crafted.
Paul says:
Sep 18, 2018
Well done, Peggy. Loved it. Heart wrenching. Dying can be painful to those around the patient.
Pam Green says:
Sep 18, 2018
Thank you for sharing, Peggy.
Jan Priddy says:
Sep 18, 2018
You point to an instant, a moment of her passing. “I can’t work, can’t think, can’t sleep. I never knew dying could take so long.” It can, in fact, take longer, and it does take forever in those of us left behind. Thank you.
Linda Malone says:
Sep 18, 2018
Maybe it’s just the coincidence that I too received the unexpected gift of a kiss when I thought my loved one was already lost to me but I think that in the telling of this very intimate story you have expressed the universality of the experience. To think, I tried to seek solace in the words of Joan Didion when Peggy Duffy was just around the corner!
LITERALLY…( no pun intended)
Linda Malone says:
Sep 18, 2018
Maybe it’s just the coincidence that I too received the gift of an unexpected kiss when I thought my loved one was already lost to me but your very intimate story expresses a universality that made me smile and cry at the same time. To think I tried to find solace in Joan Didion when Peggy Duffy was right around the corner…..LITERALLY ! (No pun intended).
Krisz says:
Sep 19, 2018
Having a close friend who’s going through a similar situation right now, this story touched my heart in a special way. So many emotions packed in one short piece of writing. Your words express so much. Lovely writing.
Ann V. Klotz says:
Sep 20, 2018
exquisite–thank you.
Joanne Glenn says:
Sep 20, 2018
So beautiful, so poignant, brought me to tears as well.
Anne says:
Sep 21, 2018
Lovely and true.
Mary says:
Sep 22, 2018
Peggy, your story is poignant and lovely. It drew me into your parent’s room where I found myself reliving my own mother’s passing. I miss my mom, but your wriiting awakened my memories and gave me a few precious more.
Thank you. Keep writing.
Victoria says:
Sep 23, 2018
So beautiful. I cared for my father at his end on this earth and now live with my 90 year old mother so that she can stay in her home. Your words brought me to tears at the beauty, the drawn-out waiting and the brevity of a life that comes to its end. Thank you.
Pam Andersen says:
Sep 25, 2018
Love and hope. Your mother was always there, hidden inside, and could now somehow finally show you again she loved you. The best. Thank you for sharing.
Armen Bacon says:
Sep 26, 2018
These words completely dissolved me – swept me back in time to six months ago when I was at my mother’s bedside while she fought crossing the precipice to “the next place.” As writers, many experiencing this passage of our parents’ generation – we really should create an anthology of moments such as these. They are beautiful, haunting, sacred, and forever etched in our hearts.
Toby Goode says:
Sep 26, 2018
Absolutely beautiful. Thank you for sharing your gift.
Kimberly says:
Sep 28, 2018
Beautifully written, Peggy. I, too, was drawn into the room of my mother’s leave taking. Remembering the one tear that trickled .
Sandy says:
Sep 28, 2018
Beautiful writing that builds to a poignant and moving ending that is specific and universal at the same time. The line ending with “I never knew dying could take so long” took me back to my mother’s years long slide to death. Your writing draws me in and fills me with emotions. Thank you.
Nicole Cyrus says:
Oct 1, 2018
Thank you for sharing this lovely piece.
Tanya says:
Oct 16, 2018
Thank you for sharing this experience.
Bethany says:
Oct 16, 2018
Thank you for this — emotional and so well-written.
June Sylvester Saraceno says:
Nov 25, 2018
Beautiful. Thank you.
Jodi says:
Jan 4, 2019
Beautifully sparse and revelatory. Love how you handled the narrator responses in italics.
Jennifer says:
Nov 29, 2021
Brilliantly written.