The most important thing writing has taught me is this: the more vulnerable you allow yourself to be, the stronger you become. It sounds counter-intuitive, I know. It sounds like bullshit. Here’s the thing: you can’t change the past, but if you can face it, both the present and the future will shift. And it’s a hell of a lot easier than wasting your energy keeping something underground. When you drag the shameful thing out of the dark, its power lessens. It is finite. It has edges. You look at it in the light, and in the light you write it down, and in the writing you may find a way to forgive yourself, and in the telling you grow stronger because you have made something new out of it, you have given it shape and meaning.
So when you write about your life, don’t skip over the hard parts. What would be the point? Who would you be fooling? Yourself? Oh please. I learned this the hard way, so stricken with shame that I needed to find a way out. My husband was hit by a car, and he was left with a traumatic brain injury so severe he could not live at home. He was taken to a facility in upstate New York. Once a week I drove up to see him, but it felt so infrequent and so short were the visits that I sold my apartment in the city and bought a house nearby and slowly I began to put a life together. I made new friends, I had a yard where my dogs could run free, I was writing and teaching. Sometimes I was able to bring my husband home for an afternoon. I began to love my new life. But we have a habit of sabotaging ourselves, especially when things are going well, and one day I asked myself if I could wave a wand and change the past, if I could erase my husband’s tragic accident, would I? of course I would, wouldn’t I? But I hesitated, and what followed was a terrible confusion of sorrow and shame—this new life had been born of my husband’s tragedy.
I needed to write about that shame, hoping for some kind of forgiveness, hoping for clarity, but it was going nowhere. So I did what I always do when confronted by something I can’t put to rest, can’t find words for, can’t bear to know about myself. I took down my Dictionary of Indo-European Roots, because sometimes the DNA of a word answers a question you didn’t know to ask. I looked up shame, and I looked up guilt, but found nothing to enlighten me. Finally I looked up acceptance. And among the words that acceptance evolved from is one that meant “a thread used in weaving.” And in that moment my whole life changed. I understood. Acceptance. Maybe the thread frays, maybe it breaks, but you have to weave it in and then you have to keep on weaving.
Some years later a woman wrote to tell me she had spent a lifetime overwhelmed by guilt over something she had either done or failed to do, until she came across what I’d written. “I used to feel like the worst person on earth,” she wrote, “and now I just feel human.” Tell the hard truths, clear your vision, be of use.
___
Abigail Thomas has four children, twelve grandchildren and one great grandchild. She also has two old dogs and a high school education. Her books include Safekeeping; A Three Dog Life; What Comes Next and How To Like It. She celebrates her 80th birthday this year.
22 comments
Jeff says:
Sep 14, 2021
I really enjoyed this piece and it has inspired me to add this element to my writing
Agnes says:
Sep 15, 2021
Facing shame because I am old in a young world, I really appreciated your words and wisdom. There’s a poem emerging from the recent events. Thank you.
Lynette Benton says:
Nov 14, 2021
Yes, it’s shameful to be old in a young world, especially in the US. I’ve never thought of that before, so thank you for this insight.
Carole Duff says:
Sep 15, 2021
We write memoir to shine a light on shame and guilt, make peace with the past, and share peace with others. Thank you for sharing yours.
JR Rich says:
Sep 15, 2021
A masterfully written piece by one of my all time favorite writers. “Tell the hard truths…be of use” is exactly what I needed to hear at this exact moment. Thank you
Diane Reukauf says:
Sep 15, 2021
Oh thank you, Abby! Weave in the guilt, the shame, the hard parts. Acceptance. And keep on weaving. What a helpful image. Almost comforting. I feel as though I’ve just been given a gift.
Cassandra Hamilton says:
Sep 15, 2021
Unfortunately, there are no classes on vulnerability in school. There should be. Imagine the years of crappy writing avoided if we’d only learned early on how to lean into our vulnerability, aced tests on Words in Tears, Anger as Inner Expert and Finding Room Within for Conflicting Emotions. We’d be happier, nicer. Society too. Instead, the School of Hard Knocks pushes us until we in self defense learn the power of vulnerability. When we first understand it, at we’re surprised. All one had to do was not run from self and remain open? Listen? –And with that new discovery, we think we’ve found the new sliced bread, when of course all we needed to do was pick up a good book or sit with some art. All along, writers and artists have been leaving neon gifts born from vulnerability. Just like Abigail Thomas.
barbara abercrombie says:
Sep 15, 2021
I love this. Thank you, Abby –
Susan J. York says:
Sep 15, 2021
Thank you! I love the image of weaving frayed and broken threads into the fabric of my writing. It also reminds me of my love of etymology. I think I’ll order my own copy of the Dictionary of Indo-European roots as a way to dig deeper into the things I keep buried from myself.
Darlene Frank says:
Sep 15, 2021
Beautiful, and just what I needed to hear today. Thank you so much, Abigail Thomas.
Ann Fischer says:
Sep 15, 2021
What a wonderful piece. Just what I needed today. Thank you Abby.
Victoria Perry says:
Sep 15, 2021
As in life – so it is in writing about our lives – only the truth will set us free. Thank you, Abigal, for being an inspiration!
Gratefully,
Vicky
Joanne says:
Sep 15, 2021
I love this–it’s exquisite. And like many others, I feel this was written just for me. Thank you!
codesera says:
Sep 24, 2021
As in life – so it is in writing about our lives – only the truth will set us free. Thank you, Abigal, for being an inspiration!
BH says:
Sep 24, 2021
I needed this. Thank you
Leslie says:
Sep 26, 2021
Thank you, Abby. This piece answered a question I’ve been asking myself for a long time.
Lynette Benton says:
Nov 14, 2021
This essay took my breath away. It’s wrapped in Abigail Thomas’s usual brilliance and bravery. It’s rattled me. Speaking to us about vulnerability, she give us strength. What a notion. What a truth.
I will go back to an essay-in-progress and try to shamelessly face the way I’ve been avoiding revealing my flaws and my guilty part in events.
Condo PH says:
Dec 2, 2021
This is such an inspiring blog Abigail, thank you!
Bria says:
Dec 8, 2021
What a touching piece. This has inspired me a lot.
Thia Tsuruta says:
Feb 15, 2022
I just got to spend a little bit of time checking out Brevity and came up this! Thank you!!! I’ve been figuring I’d leave out going through more about some relationships, but… what you say. I’ve experienced that, how writing through not-nice times really helps! : )
Lani says:
Nov 12, 2022
“Here’s the thing: you can’t change the past, but if you can face it, both the present and the future will shift.”
So true. I used to run away when hard emotions bubble up to the surface. Beautiful piece. Thank you!
Bree says:
Mar 1, 2023
At times I tend to struggle with vulnerability because throughout the years I have developed strong boundaries, and those boundaries carried over into my writings. I don’t know if I was keeping myself out of those suppressed parts of myself or if I was keeping readers at an arm’s length. I could “mention” something without fully diving into it, and I’m aware its completely counterproductive as a writer, and as a human. Thank you for sharing this insightful essay, it will be something I will refer back to when I’m struggling with vulnerability.